Garlic Butter Steak - My Incredible Recipes (2024)

Indulge in a juicy, tender entree with this flavorful Garlic Butter Steak. It’s easy to prepare and will literally melt in your mouth with each bite.

Enjoy a flavorful cut of steak with the perfect blend of seasonings, including lightly crushed garlic and rosemary, in a homemade mushroom sauce. The steak pairs perfectly with some of your favorite sides, including mashed potatoes and broccoli.

Buttery Garlic Steak

Do you want to make a restaurant-style steak at home? If so, you’re in luck because this Buttery Garlic Steak recipe is absolutely amazing. You’ll have everyone thinking you picked this heavenly steak curbside from a steakhouse because of its incredible flavor and perfect texture. When it comes to steak, there are plenty of ways to prepare it, but this is, by far, my favorite way to do so. If you love the taste of garlic and enjoy a good steak here and there, give this recipe a try!

Why You’ll Love This Garlic Butter Steak

1. It’s a super simple dish. Once you prepare this easy steak, you can serve it with all your favorite sides.
2. The steak isn’t too tough! It has the perfect texture so that you’re not chewing it for minutes on end.
3. Everything is made from scratch, including the delicious mushroom sauce that enhances the taste of this steak even further.

Garlic Butter Steak Recipe Ingredients

• New York Strip Steak – This recipe will need four one-ounce steaks.
• Olive Oil – Grab two tablespoons of olive oil and divide them.
• Crushed Garlic – Take six cloves of garlic, lightly crush them, and divide them.
• Rosemary – Use fresh rosemary or parsley sprigs
• Baby Bella Mushrooms – Add these mushrooms to prepare a flavorful sauce.
• Heavy Cream – Thicken your sauce with heavy cream.
• Worcestershire Sauce – Enhance the flavor of the mushroom sauce with Worcestershire.

You’ll also need cracked black pepper, salt, and butter to complete this recipe for Garlic Butter Steak.

Butter Steak Recipe Variations

• If you don’t have rosemary sprigs, you can use parsley sprigs as an alternative ingredient to add flavor to your steak.
• Not a fan of mushrooms? Not a problem. You can replace the mushrooms with caramelized onions, preparing an onion sauce instead of a mushroom sauce.
• You can use your favorite blend of seasonings on this steak. However, it doesn’t need much, so salt and pepper with the creamy mushroom sauce is certainly enough!

Garlic Butter Steak Notes

• Before you begin seasoning your steaks, let them sit out on the kitchen counter for a minimum of 30 minutes. The seasoning will adhere better to both sides of the steak when it has had time to reach room temperature.
• Coat your cooking pan with oil and wait until it begins smoking before placing your steaks into the pan. It’s the best way to sear them.
• If your sauce appears too thin, continue cooking until it reduces. If it seems to be taking too long, I’d suggest adding a teaspoon of cornstarch to your mushroom sauce to thicken it up.

Buttery Garlic Steak FAQs

Do I have to use New York strip steak in this recipe?

You don’t HAVE to use the New York Strip. It’s an excellent cut of steak and will taste exceptionally well in this recipe, but you have the option of preparing this recipe with your favorite cut of steak.

What should I serve with the steak?

When it comes to side dishes, the options are endless! There are so many tasty sides to prepare with the flavorful Garlic Butter Steak. You can serve it with rice, mashed potatoes, baked potatoes, and even grilled asparagus. Serve it with whatever you enjoy eating with your meat.

What should I do if I don’t have heavy cream?

If you don’t have heavy cream but want to make that creamy and delicious mushroom sauce, combine milk with melted butter to make your own version of it. The homemade heavy cream will work well when you’re preparing your mushroom sauce.

Can I use unsalted butter?

While you can use unsalted butter in this recipe, you may need to use additional salt and pepper to enhance the taste of both your steak and the mushroom sauce.

More Recipes You Will Love!

Cajun Garlic Butter Steak Bites

Juicy Garlic Butter Steak Bites

Southern Hamburger Steaks with Onion Mushroom Gravy